Ulysses

General => Off-Topic => Topic started by: TJ123 on March 27, 2016, 12:43:40 AM

Title: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: TJ123 on March 27, 2016, 12:43:40 AM
Look, we all think ulx crashban is illegal. But you should put it as this way: does a courthouse really care if your game crashed? Crashban is NOT damaging equipment.
Enough said.
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: Caustic Soda-Senpai on March 27, 2016, 01:24:43 AM
It's not illegal, it's just an asshole (pardon my language) thing to do. It's just crashing the client. Now, if you were booting them off their networks (DoS), then it'd be illegal.
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: Megiddo on March 27, 2016, 04:17:35 AM
There are a number of perfectly legal things I could do to you if I met you in person too, and yet you would like none of them. Common decency should always be considered.
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: MrPresident on March 27, 2016, 09:19:24 AM
Why did you create an account just to post this?

It may not be illegal, but it is overly excessive and we're not going to condone that kind of thing.
There are plenty of things you CAN do but shouldn't as a server owner.

To name a few:
Rebind players' keys. (Yes, you used to be able to do this)
Crash their client or run quit on them (You also used to be able to do this)
Activate their mic without their knowledge and listen to them talk.

In my opinion, no reputable servers would ever do anything like this. There's no reason and all you're doing is being a bully because you think it's funny.

What's the difference between banning someone and banning someone while crashing their client other than causing them more frustration.
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: JamminR on March 27, 2016, 02:19:25 PM
Look, we all think ulx crashban is illegal.

I'd never heard of it until you posted it.
In the legal world, there are indeed laws in various countries that consider exploiting computer code for use other than it's original intent "illegal", especially when mis-use disturbs proper functioning of software. As I'm not aware of how/what is used in the crashban code you've just now mentioned, I imagine and would presume I'm right that whatever causes the game to crash wasn't meant to be used for malicious intent, therefore possibly making it illegal in some countries.

Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: Stickly Man! on March 28, 2016, 07:55:18 AM
To clarify for anyone who may not be aware, 'ulx crashban' is a (or one of many) third-party ULX commands that we do not have any control over. It is not included in standard ULX at all.

Expanding on Mr. President's post with an example, servers can also dump thousands of files in your data folder while playing:
https://facepunch.com/showthread.php?t=1511447
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: Timmy on March 28, 2016, 06:53:59 PM
Servers can also dump thousands of files in your data folder while playing.
This is also what ULX crashban does. Writes 2,4 GB of useless data to a player's hard drive... The command is part of ULX Extended, which is being sold on ScriptFodder.

(https://timmy.github.io/images/malicious-ulx-crashban.png)

Smh.
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: Stickly Man! on March 29, 2016, 07:22:36 AM
Yeesh :( That does make me sad. Thanks for bringing that up, Timmy!
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: Bubbie on April 01, 2016, 04:34:58 AM
Why did you create an account just to post this?

It may not be illegal, but it is overly excessive and we're not going to condone that kind of thing.
There are plenty of things you CAN do but shouldn't as a server owner.

To name a few:
Rebind players' keys. (Yes, you used to be able to do this)
Crash their client or run quit on them (You also used to be able to do this)
Activate their mic without their knowledge and listen to them talk.

In my opinion, no reputable servers would ever do anything like this. There's no reason and all you're doing is being a bully because you think it's funny.

What's the difference between banning someone and banning someone while crashing their client other than causing them more frustration.
Sadly all three of those things have been used on me and I've seen them being used on others many times.
Luckily all of the servers I have seen these on have died due to a lack of popularity.
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: LuaTenshi on May 07, 2016, 01:03:11 AM
A little late to the party but first of Vim is a nice abusive relationship, and second...

I feel that crashing players only makes them angrier then if they would be if you had just banned them, this could lead to a ton of unforeseen consequences.
Honestly I think the best course of action is to actually talk to players in a more calm environment you would be surprised how many rule breakers can become good friends.
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: Megiddo on May 07, 2016, 12:12:30 PM
Honestly I think the best course of action is to actually talk to players in a more calm environment you would be surprised how many rule breakers can become good friends.

Hah, I'll never forget the person who threatened to DDoS me because I froze him while spamming. Results vary on trying to talk to people, I suppose.
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: Bytewave on May 07, 2016, 03:37:46 PM
Honestly I think the best course of action is to actually talk to players in a more calm environment you would be surprised how many rule breakers can become good friends.
This is sound advice for pretty much anything, in-game or in-life. :p

... Vim is a nice abusive relationship...
The editor? You'll get used to (and love) it soon enough.
One of us.
One of us.
One of us.
One of us.
ONE OF US.
...
also, neovim :)
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: roastchicken on May 07, 2016, 04:50:58 PM
Hah, I'll never forget the person who threatened to DDoS me because I froze him while spamming. Results vary on trying to talk to people, I suppose.

I'll never forget the person who DID DDoS me for a few weeks because he was banned from a server. The best part was, I didn't have anything to do with it. My brother banned him.

I can't wait to get my own place.

The editor? You'll get used to (and love) it soon enough.

If I worked on a command-line or non-windows system more than once in a blue moon, I'd bother to learn Vim and I imagine it would be quite efficient to use once I got a bit of practice. Until then, it's Notepad++ for me.
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: Bytewave on May 07, 2016, 05:32:39 PM
If I worked on a command-line or non-windows system more than once in a blue moon, I'd bother to learn Vim and I imagine it would be quite efficient to use once I got a bit of practice. Until then, it's Notepad++ for me.
Don't want to get onto too big of a tangent, but they have Vim/Neovim for Windows
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: roastchicken on May 07, 2016, 06:12:10 PM
Don't want to get onto too big of a tangent, but they have Vim/Neovim for Windows

I think we've passed the event horizon on this tangent.

My reason for not using Vim isn't because I can't use it on Windows, but because I don't think it's worth the time investment to learn if I can use Notepad++ just fine.
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: LuaTenshi on May 07, 2016, 07:09:58 PM
Neovim

What's Neovim? I looked at their site and some screenshots and it just looks like Vim with a bunch of plugins.

This is how my Vim looks like, sorry there isn't a fancy background but I am taking a screenshot on Windows via SSH...
(https://i.imgur.com/76P7PlE.png)

Also I wonder what settup/plugins Timmy uses for his Vim.

Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: Bytewave on May 07, 2016, 08:17:39 PM
What's Neovim? I looked at their site and some screenshots and it just looks like Vim with a bunch of plugins.

This is how my Vim looks like, sorry there isn't a fancy background but I am taking a screenshot on Windows via SSH...
<IMAGE REMOVED>

Also I wonder what settup/plugins Timmy uses for his Vim.


Neovim is a refactored Vim clone with more extendability. The two are rather similar, I just prefer neovim and would recommend it purely because it's cleaner.
Speaking of plugins... I really want to know what all you're using.

also, mods might want to split this thread, it's getting a little long
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: JamminR on May 07, 2016, 08:28:00 PM
I could split, but considering crashban guy was only here once just to create a single post that made no sense and was incorrect in many countries regarding it's legality, I really don't care that it's gone into a worm hole.
Just stop quoting each other if a large image is included, or remove the image from the quote.
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: Bytewave on May 07, 2016, 09:50:31 PM
Just stop quoting each other if a large image is included, or remove the image from the quote.
Whoops, missed that.
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: Timmy on May 08, 2016, 02:10:11 AM
Also I wonder what settup/plugins Timmy uses for his Vim.
Not entirely sure. My .vimrc file was auto-generated by http://vim-bootstrap.com... I only ever use Vim for previewing files and making small changes. :-[
Title: Re: ulx crashban: Why it's NOT illegal, and you're fine to use it.
Post by: LuaTenshi on May 08, 2016, 02:54:01 PM
Not entirely sure. My .vimrc file was auto-generated by http://vim-bootstrap.com... I only ever use Vim for previewing files and making small changes. :-[

No worries I my self got a premade .vimrc file from a persons github, although I did make some slightl changes because the person who made the vimrc really hates it when people use the arrow keys and wants you to use the home row keys, but I prefer the arrow keys as personally I find them faster and easier to use. To each their own I guess.